Garage Sale Low Pro Holster Fit Guide: Hellcat Pro vs Glock 34/17/19

Quick answer

Choose the Garage Sale Low Pro for Glock 34/17/19 if you carry a double-stack Glock and want the most concealable IWB option. Choose the Hellcat Pro version if you carry the smaller Springfield Hellcat Pro and want the same Low Pro features in a shorter package.

The fit decision starts with your pistol, not the price

These two Low Pro holsters are molded for different pistols, so the first rule is simple: match the holster to the gun you actually carry. The Glock version covers Glock 34, 17, and 19 Gen 2-6 models. The Hellcat Pro version is built for the Springfield Hellcat Pro. A holster for one will not properly retain the other.

That means the garage sale low pro holster fit question is really a gun-size question. Full-size and compact Glocks have different slide lengths and grip heights than the Hellcat Pro, and the holster shell has to support the frame and trigger guard correctly.

What both Low Pro holsters share

Both models use the same Low Pro design: two points of retention for a snug fit, a modwing claw that presses against your belt to pull the gun closer to your body, and compatibility with red dots, suppressor height sights, and threaded barrels. That shared feature set is why this low pro holster buying guide can focus on pistol fit rather than retraining you on the holster style.

The claw matters most for concealed carry because it reduces the overall imprint of the pistol. If you already know you want that feature, the remaining choice is simply which pistol you carry.

Where the Hellcat Pro version makes more sense

The Hellcat Pro is a smaller pistol than the Glock 34 or 17, and the holster is made specifically for it. If you carry the Hellcat Pro every day and want the most concealable IWB option from this line, the Hellcat Pro version is the direct fit. It also keeps the same red-dot and threaded-barrel accommodations, so you do not give up optic compatibility by going smaller.

One limitation to note: the catalog does not list a light-bearing option for either Garage Sale Low Pro model. If you run a weapon-mounted light, treat that as a separate decision and confirm compatibility before buying.

Where the Glock 34/17/19 version makes more sense

The Glock version covers three popular double-stack models across Gen 2-6, which makes it the practical choice if you rotate between a Glock 19 for carry and a Glock 17 or 34 for range or competition. The holster is made to accommodate red dots, suppressor height sights, and threaded barrels, so a dot-equipped Glock 19 or a threaded-barrel setup is within the intended design.

Keep in mind that the Glock version is molded for the Glock family, not the Hellcat Pro. If you own both pistols, you need one holster per pistol rather than expecting one shell to fit both.

Decision rules for choosing your Low Pro holster

• Match the holster to the pistol you carry most: If your daily carry is a Glock 19, 17, or 34 Gen 2-6, choose the Glock version. If your daily carry is a Springfield Hellcat Pro, choose the Hellcat Pro version. Do not buy based on price alone; the shell must match the pistol for retention and safety.
• Check your optic and muzzle setup before ordering: Both holsters are made to accommodate red dots, suppressor height sights, and threaded barrels. If you use a compensator, the catalog notes you should inform the maker so the fit can be confirmed. A compensator is the one accessory that may require a conversation before purchase.
• Decide whether you need light compatibility: The supplied catalog facts do not list a light-bearing option for either Garage Sale Low Pro model. If you carry a weapon-mounted light, verify compatibility directly before buying. Treat light compatibility as an open question, not an assumed feature.

Product facts at a glance

• Garage Sale Low Pro - Fits Glock 34/17/19 Gen 2-6: Fits Glock 34, 17, and 19 Gen 2-6 and comes with two retention points plus a modwing claw. This lets you use one holster across several double-stack Glock sizes while keeping the grip pulled toward your body.

  

• Garage Sale Low Pro - Springfield Hellcat Pro: Built for the Springfield Hellcat Pro with the same Low Pro retention and modwing claw design. Hellcat Pro carriers get the concealment features of the Low Pro line in a shell sized to their smaller pistol.

  

Which Low Pro holster fits your carry

Best for

• Glock 19, 17, or 34 Gen 2-6 owners who want one concealable IWB holster for multiple double-stack Glocks
• Hellcat Pro owners who want the Low Pro claw and retention design in a pistol-specific shell

Not for

• Carriers who need a confirmed weapon-mounted light compatible holster
• Anyone carrying a pistol other than the Glock 34/17/19 Gen 2-6 or Springfield Hellcat Pro